I vote for both A & B
I would go with either, A or B. I’m more about chemistry and personality. If either had a tendency to drink too much then I’d choose the other.
I have this unfortunate association with alcohol and violence, and in particular drunken men and violence against women. Sorry, but I find excessive alcohol use repulsive.
Maybe you can take further inspiration from the “other thread” and do an incoherent abusive (probably violent if provoked) drunken bloke v sober sophisticated challenge :)
James Bond v Rab C Nesbitt