Boards Index General discussion Getting serious Don't go wasting our time……………….

Viewing 10 posts - 11 through 20 (of 25 total)
  • Author
    Posts
  • #1095406

    Originals aren’t always the best version ……  just sayin’ B-)

    #1095409

    Nope, they aren’t.

    I doubt that a poor black woman living in the Charleston slums in the 1930s would be wearing high-heeled shoes, either.

    But it’s interesting.

    Not sure what the best version is..maybe the louis armstrong/ella fitzgerald??

    #1095410

    Possibly ….I love this version though, love her voice…..

    https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=OeelXbuXkGU
    1 member liked this post.
    #1095411

    yeah, it’s good.

    I always imagined the song to be rough, full of character.

    I think it was originally meant for a very ‘operatic’ voice, though, as Mr G had pretensions.

    Unlike me :-)

    #1095412

    I think an operatic voice would kill it ….. needs a bit of grit … we are talking cotton and catfish here,  not cucumber butties and earl grey B-)

    #1095414

    absolutely.

    Hasn’t stopped a lot of opera people slumming it in the Charleston swamps, though.

    Mr G wanted to be a serious classical composer, and to write popular music at the same time. The result was this ‘folk opera’.

    What was revolutionary about it at the time (1935) was the all-black cast.

    But what was needed was a voice like Rebecca Ferguson’s.

    #1095415

    I’m glad you like her :-)

    #1095416

    Oh dear ! I just realised we hi-jacked this thread ! So not such a waste of time after all ! :-)

    Night :bye:

     

     

    B-)

    #1095426

    Hi jack……who do you mean by jack? is he a reg or new person?………LMAO…Actually the reason i laugh is because of the film Titanic where kate is discussing Froyd around the table and Bruce Ismay says……. froyd..who is he? is he a passenger on the ship?…LMAO

    Awesome !

    #1095427

    Reminds me of a joke where the terrorist gets on the plane and sees an old friend…he shouts out…Hi Jack…….LOLOLOLOL

Viewing 10 posts - 11 through 20 (of 25 total)

Get involved in this discussion! Log in or register now to have your say!